Latimer Tuition

Navigation

Latimer Tuition

Parents’ guide to tutoring choices

School Tutoring vs Private Tutoring: Which Is Right for Your Child?

School support is often the best first step when it is targeted and connected to classwork. Private tuition may help when your child needs more individualisation, flexibility or direct parent communication than the school can provide.

Find a tutorSee how Latimer works

Editorial

  • Portrait of Robin GibbonsLead authorFounder & CEO·Latimer Tuition
  • Reviewed byHeather LatimerTutor Matching & Customer Service·Latimer Tuition
  • Published
  • Updated
  • Last reviewed

Current answer

School tutoring or private tutoring: the quick answer

School tutoring vs private tutoring does not have one evidence-based winner. Well-targeted school support is often the sensible first option when it addresses a clear gap, connects with normal lessons and is reviewed over time. Private tuition can be a useful complement when a child needs more individual attention, a different pace, flexible timing or more direct parent–tutor communication than the school can realistically provide.

The most important question is not who arranged the tuition, but whether the teaching is well matched to the child. The Education Endowment Foundation’s guidance captures the central principle:

“Tuition is more likely to make an impact if it is additional to and explicitly linked with normal lessons.” — Education Endowment Foundation

Before adding anything, identify the learning gap, understand what the school is already doing, check that the extra workload is manageable and set a review point. There is no strong head-to-head evidence showing that privately purchased tuition is automatically better than equivalent school-led support.

What school-led tutoring and the evidence actually mean

“School tutoring” is an umbrella term rather than one standard service. The format, group size, timing, staff and reporting can all vary. The evidence below describes tutoring formats and good practice; it does not prove that a school-funded or privately purchased arrangement is better in every case.

School-led tutoring

Targeted academic support arranged through the school. It may be one-to-one, small-group or part of a wider intervention. In England, current pupil premium guidance places targeted academic support alongside high-quality teaching and action on non-academic barriers; this is an England framework, not a single UK-wide programme.

One-to-one tuition

Intensive individual support in which one teacher, teaching assistant, tutor or other adult works directly with one pupil. The Education Endowment Foundation estimates an average impact of about five additional months’ progress.

Small-group tuition

Targeted tuition in which one adult works with two to five pupils. The Education Endowment Foundation estimates an average impact of about four additional months’ progress.

What the figures do — and do not — show

The EEF figures are evidence-summary averages from reviews last updated in July 2021. They are not guarantees for an individual child, and they do not compare otherwise identical school-led and private arrangements.

One-to-one is not always better

Some studies find groups of two or three equally effective or more effective than one-to-one tuition. Subject, pupil need, group composition, tutor quality, frequency and connection to class teaching can matter as much as the exact group size.

School tutoring vs private tutoring: side-by-side

These are typical differences, not fixed rules. A strong school intervention can be highly personalised, while a private arrangement can be poorly matched or disconnected from classwork.

Compare how each model may work in practice and use the final column to test the fit for your child.

FactorSchool-led supportPrivate tuitionQuestions to ask

Connection to classwork

Often sits within school systems, making it easier to use teacher input, curriculum plans and relevant assessment information.

Can complement classwork well, but the tutor may need the parent and school to clarify topics, methods and current gaps.

What is being taught now, and how will the extra work reinforce rather than compete with it?

Personalisation

May be individual or group-based. The degree of tailoring depends on staffing, group size and the purpose of the intervention.

Can offer more control over tutor choice, pace and subject focus, particularly in a consistent one-to-one arrangement.

What specific gap will be addressed, and how will teaching change in response to the child’s progress?

Group size

May be one-to-one or a small group; EEF defines small-group tuition as one adult with two to five pupils.

Often one-to-one, but private tuition can also be shared or group-based. One-to-one is not automatically more effective.

Is the group size appropriate for the child’s need, confidence and level of participation?

Timing and continuity

Works around the school timetable and staffing. It may happen outside lessons or replace some lesson time over several weeks or a term.

Can offer evenings, weekends or a timetable chosen with the family, subject to tutor availability.

Will the timing support learning without removing essential rest, activities or recovery time?

Parent communication and reporting

Progress may be tracked within school systems, but the frequency and detail of parent updates vary.

Direct contact can make goals and updates easier to agree. Reporting still varies by tutor and should be discussed before lessons begin.

What will be reported, how often, and against what starting point or agreed goal?

Tutor choice

The school normally chooses the staff member, provider or intervention model.

The family can usually compare subject experience, teaching background, availability and approach before deciding.

Does the tutor have relevant experience for this subject, phase and particular learning need?

Safeguarding context

Takes place within the school’s safeguarding arrangements, staff responsibilities and concern-reporting procedures.

Parents should understand the tutor or agency’s checks, references, boundaries, online arrangements and process for raising a concern.

Which role-appropriate disclosure system applies, and what safeguards exist beyond the certificate itself?

Most useful when

The school has identified the gap, can provide suitable support and can connect it closely to everyday teaching.

A defined need requires more individual time, flexibility, tutor choice or parent visibility than the school can provide.

What useful condition would private tuition add that is genuinely missing now?

Common watch-outs

The intervention may be too broad, too short, poorly timed or unclear to the family; group size and reporting can vary.

Extra work can duplicate school, overload the child or become a disconnected second curriculum. A disclosure check alone is not proof of suitability.

What is the review date, what evidence will show progress, and when would you change or stop the support?

Which option is more likely to fit your child’s situation?

Use these patterns as decision aids rather than diagnoses. The right next step depends on the identified need, the quality of support already available and the child’s capacity for more work.

Recommendation

School support may be enough

This is more likely when the school can name the gap, explain the format and duration, link the work to class teaching and show how progress will be reviewed. Example: the school has arranged a defined small-group intervention for a term, the class teacher knows the goals and there is a review date. It may be sensible to let that support work before adding a second programme.

Recommendation

Private tuition may add useful capacity

This is more likely when there is a defined subject need, the school cannot offer enough individual time or flexibility, and the child can manage the extra commitment. Example: a pupil has a specific algebra gap and would benefit from focused practice at a manageable pace, with the tutor using current class topics rather than teaching an unrelated sequence.

Recommendation

Pause before adding tuition

Pause when the main concern may be attendance, wellbeing, behaviour, school refusal, an unmet additional need or an already overloaded week. Example: where anxiety-related absence is driving missed learning, more worksheets may add pressure without addressing the reason the child is not accessing lessons. Tuition should not replace appropriate school, statutory, clinical or therapeutic support.

Before you add private tuition

A defined purpose makes it easier to choose the right support and to stop paying for work that is duplicative or unhelpful.

  • Name the exact gap

    Replace “falling behind” with a specific goal, such as reading fluency, algebraic manipulation, essay structure or confidence applying a known method.

  • Understand the school’s current support

    Ask what is already in place, how often it happens, the group size, intended duration and how progress is being monitored.

  • Check whether the barrier is mainly academic

    Attendance, wellbeing, behaviour or an unmet additional need may require a different response. Do not ask tuition to substitute for the right form of support.

  • Protect the child’s workload

    Choose a frequency and time that leave room for rest, family life, activities and recovery. More contact time is not automatically better.

  • Connect the work to school

    Agree how the tutor will use current topics, teacher feedback or general curriculum information without creating a disconnected second track.

  • Agree what useful reporting looks like

    Ask for clear goals and proportionate evidence, such as brief session notes, work samples or progress against an agreed starting point.

  • Complete wider safeguarding checks

    Ask about the role-appropriate disclosure process, references, identity, relevant experience, professional boundaries and how concerns can be raised.

  • Set a review and stopping point

    Agree when you will review progress and what would justify continuing, changing the approach or stopping.

Message to a teacher or relevant support lead

A message to your child’s school

When this applies

Use this before arranging private tuition, or after a tutor has started if you want the two strands of support to be better aligned. You want to understand the school’s current intervention and ask for proportionate coordination without assuming that detailed pupil records can be released.

Suggested wording

Hello [name], I’m considering private tuition for [child] in [subject]. Could you tell me what support is already in place, the specific gaps or goals being worked on, how often the support happens and how progress is reviewed? If we add a tutor, is there any general class focus or information that can appropriately be shared so the extra work complements rather than duplicates school?

Why this helps

It asks for the purpose, format and review of existing support. It also invites useful coordination while recognising that the school must decide what information can lawfully and proportionately be shared.

DBS, PVG and AccessNI: what parents should ask

Disclosure systems differ across the UK, and eligibility depends on the role and activity. Ask about the appropriate current process, but remember that a disclosure check is only one part of safer recruitment.

A nation-by-nation guide to the main disclosure systems relevant to private tutors.

NationSystemCurrent practical processWhat a parent can askEssential caveat

England and Wales

Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS)

From 21 January 2026, an eligible self-employed tutor can apply for an Enhanced or Enhanced with Barred List(s) check through a DBS Umbrella Body. The parent cannot apply on the tutor’s behalf.

Ask which level is lawful for the role. For a certificate, ask to see the original and check identity details, the relevant workforce and issue date.

Eligibility is role-specific. A DBS check is one part of safer recruitment and may not cover overseas history.

Scotland

Protecting Vulnerable Groups (PVG) scheme

PVG membership is required for a regulated role. Membership lasts five years, and Disclosure Scotland continues to monitor scheme members while they remain in the scheme.

Ask whether the tutoring activity is a regulated role and what current PVG membership or disclosure applies.

The role must be assessed under current Scottish rules; do not assume that every tutoring arrangement is a regulated role.

Northern Ireland

AccessNI

An eligible self-employed tutor can apply for an appropriate standard or enhanced check through an AccessNI Umbrella Body. Official guidance gives a private maths tutor working regularly with children as an enhanced-check example.

Ask which check is appropriate for the actual activity and how the tutor can show the current result.

Eligibility remains role- and activity-specific; not every tutor is entitled or required to obtain the same level.

Across the UK

Wider safeguarding checks

Combine the appropriate disclosure process with identity checks, references, relevant experience, clear professional boundaries and a clear way to report concerns.

How are references checked? What are the online or in-person boundaries? Who receives a concern and what happens next?

A clean or current disclosure does not prove overall competence, judgement or suitability.

What to ask a prospective private tutor

Choose for fit, teaching quality and safeguarding rather than availability alone. For an England or Wales DBS certificate, official guidance is concrete:

“Copies or digital photographs are not acceptable and must be rejected.” — Disclosure and Barring Service

That certificate instruction does not describe PVG or AccessNI document handling, so use the correct process for the nation and role.

  • Relevant experience

    What experience do you have with this subject, phase and specific learning need? How would you adapt if the first approach did not work?

  • Starting point and goals

    How will you identify the starting point, set a manageable goal and decide what to teach first?

  • Connection to classwork

    How will you use current school topics, teacher feedback or curriculum information without simply repeating lessons?

  • Progress reporting

    What will you report, how often and against what evidence? Ask whether session notes, work samples, homework or review summaries are included rather than assumed.

  • Frequency and workload

    How will lesson frequency, homework and review points be agreed so that the support remains useful and manageable?

  • Role-appropriate checks

    Which disclosure system and level lawfully apply to this role, how current is the evidence and how can it be checked through the appropriate process?

  • References, identity and boundaries

    What references and identity checks have been completed? What are the rules for communication, cancellations, one-to-one contact and raising a concern?

  • Online lesson safety

    Which platform will be used? For a younger learner, what should the parent know about lesson times, being nearby, cameras, chat, recording and concern escalation?

Sources and further reading

These research, official and Latimer pages support the evidence, safeguarding and service information used in this guide. Dates are shown where they are especially relevant.

  • Tutoring evidence — EEF: One to one tuition

    Review last updated July 2021 · average impact, targeting and linkage to normal lessons

    Open source

  • Tutoring evidence — EEF: Small group tuition

    Review last updated July 2021 · two-to-five-pupil groups, average impact and delivery considerations

    Open source

  • School support — GOV.UK: Pupil premium overview

    Updated 11 May 2026 · England framework for evidence-informed support

    Open source

  • Information sharing — GOV.UK: Sharing personal data

    Updated 9 July 2026 · England school guidance on lawful and proportionate sharing

    Open source

  • Safeguarding information — ICO guidance for the UK education sector

    Accessed 16 July 2026 · UK education-sector safeguarding information sharing; the ICO says this guidance is under review after the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025

    Open source

  • DBS — Guidance for private individuals hiring self-employed workers

    Updated 23 January 2026 · eligible applications and certificate checks in England and Wales

    Open source

  • DBS — Eligibility guidance

    Updated 1 July 2026 · role-specific eligibility for check levels

    Open source

  • DBS — Safer recruitment guidance

    Updated 1 July 2026 · why a disclosure check is only one part of safer recruitment

    Open source

  • Scotland — mygov.scot: Protecting Vulnerable Groups scheme

    Updated 12 June 2026 · regulated roles and current PVG membership

    Open source

  • Northern Ireland — nidirect: Checks for self-employed or personal employees

    Accessed 16 July 2026 · AccessNI process and role-specific eligibility

    Open source

  • Latimer Tuition — How online tutoring works

    Accessed 16 July 2026 · tutor contact, introductory meetings and pay-as-you-go process

    Open source

  • Latimer Tuition — Find an online tutor

    Accessed 16 July 2026 · tutor filters and profile information

    Open source

  • Latimer Tuition — Safeguarding and child protection

    Last reviewed 29 May 2026 · Latimer’s stated checks and online-safety arrangements

    Open source

Related guidance

More guidance from this section

More guidance from this part of the Ed Centre that may help with the same decision, stage or next step.

Related guidance

Does my child need a tutor?

Help parents decide whether tutoring is the right next step, what to try first, and how to choose safely if tutoring is appropriate.

Support and clarity

Frequently asked questions

Straight answers to the questions people ask most often.

Is school tutoring as effective as private tutoring?

There is no direct high-quality evidence showing that either model is universally more effective. EEF evidence summaries find positive average effects for both one-to-one and small-group tuition, but the strongest conditions are accurate targeting, good teaching, connection to normal lessons and progress review. School support may have stronger built-in curriculum alignment; private tuition may add individualisation, timing flexibility and parent contact where those are missing.

Is one-to-one tuition always better than small-group tuition?

No. The EEF reports positive average effects for both formats, and some studies find groups of two or three equally effective or more effective than one-to-one support. Tutor quality, subject, pupil need, group composition, frequency and how well the teaching is delivered all affect the result.

Does my child need private tutoring if school support is already in place?

First ask what exact gap the school has identified, what support is being provided, its goals and duration, and how progress will be reviewed. Private tuition is more defensible when it fills a defined need or adds individual time or flexibility that the school cannot provide. It may be unnecessary if the existing intervention is specific, well coordinated and showing progress.

Should I tell the school about a private tutor?

Usually, yes. Letting the school know can help the tutor’s work complement rather than duplicate class teaching. Tell the school the broad purpose and ask what general curriculum focus, target or feedback can appropriately be shared. Do not assume that detailed records or sensitive information can be released informally.

Will the school share information with a private tutor?

Sometimes, but sharing is not automatic. In England, a school needs a compelling reason, a lawful basis and a proportionate decision about who needs which information and why. Where consent is relevant, age and parental responsibility can affect who gives it. Necessary safeguarding information sharing is treated differently and does not usually depend on consent.

What safeguarding checks should I ask a private tutor for?

Ask which role-appropriate disclosure system and level apply in the tutor’s UK nation and circumstances. For an England or Wales DBS certificate, ask to see the original and check identity details, workforce and issue date. Also ask about references, relevant experience, professional boundaries and how concerns are reported, because a DBS, PVG or AccessNI disclosure is not proof of overall suitability on its own.

What is the difference between DBS, PVG and AccessNI?

DBS is the criminal-record checking system used in England and Wales. PVG is Scotland’s scheme for regulated roles, and AccessNI is Northern Ireland’s disclosure service. Eligibility and the appropriate level depend on the role and activity, so the same requirement should not be stated across all four nations.

When is private tuition not the right answer?

It may be the wrong next step when the main barrier is attendance, wellbeing, behaviour, school refusal or another unmet need rather than a defined academic gap. It may also add little when school support is already specific, well coordinated and working. Tuition should not replace appropriate school action or statutory, clinical or therapeutic support.

Sources and references

Sources and references

Official guidance

Peer-reviewed research

Internal pages