Use subject-specific evidence to review progress
Progress evidence should show what the learner can now do with greater accuracy, clarity or independence. It needs enough similarity to the baseline for a fair comparison and enough variation to show application rather than memorised repetition. English, Maths and Science therefore require different observations even when one person teaches them.
Feedback is most useful when it identifies the misunderstanding or gap, gives the learner a next action and informs the following teaching decision. Marks can contribute, but they should not stand alone. An improved paragraph, a justified mathematical method and a stronger scientific conclusion are different achievements. Review the three records together only when deciding how the timetable or tutor arrangement should change. Targeted tutoring can support progress, but no page or lesson structure can guarantee a result.
- English evidence
- Compare selection of evidence, organisation, language control or independent editing on tasks with similar demands.
- Maths evidence
- Track method choice, accuracy, connected reasoning and transfer to a problem whose presentation has changed.
- Science evidence
- Compare conceptual explanation, treatment of data, practical reasoning or justified conclusions within the applicable course.
- Independence evidence
- Record which prompts, models or scaffolds were needed and whether that support can now be reduced.
- Feedback action
- State what the learner should try next and what the tutor will check before moving to a harder demand.
- Plan decision
- Continue, reteach, revisit prerequisite knowledge, change the resource or shift time to a different subject.